
The first 25 seconds of Mayer Hawthorne’s “A Strange Arrangement” opens with a harmonic and dissident a cappella phrase, titled “Prelude”. It’s an ear-pleasing way to start an album with Hawthorne’s voice overlaying on top of itself in complex harmonies. It grabs your attention and lets you know that yes, you’re listening to something different. Something you normally wouldn’t, but hang on, you’re probably going to like it.
The next song, “A Strange Arrangement” begins with just piano, bass and Hawthorne’s breathy high voice. Hawthorne’s voice is soothing, vibrato-free and light. He doesn’t have a wide range, or chooses to stick with mid-to-high tones. I reiterate, though, it’s pleasant. His voice is incredibly well suited to his music – strong melodies, simple beats horns, because a soul album is not a soul album without horns. It takes a full 35 seconds until drums come into the song, and shortly thereafter flutes round out the sound.
“A Strange Arrangement” sets the whole tone of the album. It feels like listening to a 40-year-old, lo-fi record. The only thing lacking are record pops. Everything is authentic, every note is perfect. It feels like more of a soul album than most soul albums from the 1960’s. It’s simple, repetitive and emotional.
For me, track 4, “Maybe So, Maybe No” is the best song on the album. It has everything you need in a song: horns, strong beat, classic soul guitar and bass, and vocal harmonies that drive the meaning of the song. “Maybe So, Maybe No” is about not knowing where you stand with the one you are obsessed with. That precarious time where you over-analyze every aspect about that person and you wonder if it will ever work out. Could that person love you as much as you want them to? For anyone who has ever been in love (and lost) this song, and album, will resonate with you. Hawthorne does this while putting exactly the right music to your heart cracking in two.
“Make Her Mine” is a very upbeat and catchy track smack in the middle of the album, The placement comes as a much needed break from slitting one’s wrists or crying in one’s beer. Really, that’s this albums greatest strength, it does not allow itself to become monotonous. Another notable song, “One Track Mind” lyrically makes this feminist want to throw up. A woman spending her man’s money because she can, and he let’s her because, “she’s so fine” is indeed, gag inducing. But here again, the music is so upbeat and fun, that I actually sang along and enjoyed every minute of it.
The track, “The Ills” comes in just second after “Maybe So, Maybe No” for me. A nice fast beat pushes this song , strong horns, and Hawthorne’s super high oooh’s coast freely in the background over his version of a social anthem. Incredibly upbeat in tempo and in melody, you would dance to it immediately if you didn’t take the time to listen to the lyrics. Hawthorne doesn’t say much noteworthy, or that hasn’t been said, about the Hurricane Katrina tragedy. He keeps it simple and concisely acknowledges that bad things happen. What are you going to do about it? Are you going to get back up? Do you have a choice? You WILL get back up, because survival is paramount to the human experience. The pushing beat of the drums steers his vision home, as you can’t sit still long enough to think about your problems. The music is too good, and life is too short, so fuck it. Get out there and shake it.
“Shiny and New” is forgettable. Probably the most expendable track on the album. While it does showcase Hawthorne’s ridiculously high voice, that’s about it. “Let Me Know” is heavy on the piano, filled with choruses of doo-doo-doo-doos, and is much more interesting than the proceeding song. Hawthorne’s songwriting ability really shines when he writes about the darker side of love. The music is more intuitive, lyrically he is stronger, and the listener enjoys reveling in the melancholy of it all.
The album closes with “Green Eyed Love”. Written in minor, this offering deals with being in love with someone that is wrong for you and denying said love. (Who hasn’t been there, amirightladies?) He couldn’t have chosen a more perfect track to end the album. Hawthorne’s chorus of “They say, they say, they say you’re no good for me, but I know, I know, I know, that’s a lie” mixed with a sick guitar solo and simple piano chords is like putting sprinkles on a sundae.
The most remarkable fact? He played every instrument on the album, as well as singing every part. This album is truly his baby, and if you don’t like it, the responsibility lies squarely on his shoulders. I grew up listening to soul and Motown, just like the 29 year old Hawthorne. Only instead of growing up in Kansas like I did, he grew up just outside of Detroit in Ann Arbor. He’s well versed in even the most subtle nuances of soul. He’s done his research and his homework well. But instead of just regurgitating what others have done before him, he gives us something new, something special, and something that should have a spot in any soul lover’s collection.